Choosing between Brightspeed and EarthLink comes down to understanding exactly how each company operates. While both offer internet access to millions of American households, their underlying business models are completely different.
Brightspeed is an infrastructure owner. They physically own and operate the legacy CenturyLink copper DSL lines and the new state-of-the-art fiber-optic networks in their 20-state footprint. EarthLink, on the other hand, is a third-party reseller. They do not own the network infrastructure in your neighborhood; instead, they rent bandwidth from major providers (including Brightspeed, AT&T, and Frontier) and sell it to you under the EarthLink brand name.
In this expert, unbiased comparison, we look closely at Brightspeed and EarthLink to compare their speeds, 2026 plans, monthly pricing, and customer service to help you make the right choice.
TIP
Who is running the best promo in your neighborhood today? Call our neutral home broadband experts to see which provider has the highest speeds and best pricing available at your exact zip code.
The Comparison at a Glance
| Feature | Brightspeed | EarthLink | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Business Model | Direct Infrastructure Owner | Third-Party Reseller | Brightspeed (Cheaper direct cost) |
| Connection Types | Fiber & DSL | Fiber, DSL, Satellite, & 5G | EarthLink (More technology options) |
| Download Speeds | Up to 8,000 Mbps | Up to 5,000 Mbps | Brightspeed (Higher max speed limit) |
| Contract Rules | No Contracts | Often Requires 1-Year Contract | Brightspeed (More flexible) |
| Data Caps | Truly Unlimited | Truly Unlimited | Tie (Zero overage fees) |
| Starting Price | $29.99/mo | ~$39.95/mo | Brightspeed (Lower starting rate) |
| Customer Service | Improving (Average) | Premium (Highly Rated) | EarthLink (Better support reputation) |
Speed & Network Infrastructure
Because EarthLink leases its lines from providers like Brightspeed, the raw speed you receive from both companies at your specific address is often identical. The difference lies in what you are paying for that speed.
Brightspeed: Direct Fiber and DSL
Brightspeed is investing heavily in upgrading old copper DSL lines to highly capable XGS-PON fiber networks.
- Performance: If Brightspeed Fiber is available at your home, you will receive highly stable, symmetrical download and upload speeds ranging from 200 Mbps up to 8 Gbps.
- The Caveat: In areas where Brightspeed has not yet laid fiber, you will be stuck on their legacy DSL network, which often maxes out at around 10 Mbps to 100 Mbps.
EarthLink: The Network Renter
EarthLink partners with the largest networks in the country. If you buy EarthLink service in a Brightspeed territory, EarthLink is likely routing your internet over Brightspeed's same physical wires.
- Performance: EarthLink's speed will match whatever physical infrastructure they are renting. If they rent an AT&T Fiber line for you, you get excellent fiber speeds. If they rent a legacy DSL line, their speeds will be slow.
- The Advantage: EarthLink's vast web of partnerships means they are available almost everywhere in the US, making them a highly accessible option for rural or hard-to-reach homes.
🏆 Speed Winner: Tie. Because EarthLink often uses Brightspeed's physical lines, the actual speed to your home is identical. However, Brightspeed wins on transparency since you are buying directly from the source.
Plan & Pricing Comparison (2026)
This is where the two companies diverge significantly. Because EarthLink acts as a middleman, its prices are almost always higher than buying directly from the infrastructure owner.
Brightspeed Plans & Pricing
Brightspeed offers highly aggressive pricing, especially on their newer fiber networks, because they do not have to pay wholesale fees to another company:
- Fiber 200 Mbps: $29.99/mo (Promo Rate)
- Fiber 500 Mbps: $39.99/mo (Promo Rate)
- Fiber 1 Gig (940 Mbps): $49.99/mo (Promo Rate)
- DSL (Up to 100 Mbps): ~$50.00/mo (Standard Rate)
*Fiber prices reflect promotional periods; standard rates apply after the first year. Equipment is often included for free.
EarthLink Plans & Pricing
EarthLink's pricing is generally higher. They charge a premium to cover their wholesale costs and to fund their highly-rated customer support centers:
- EarthLink Internet (Various DSL/Cable speeds): Starts around 39.95/moto49.95/mo
- EarthLink Fiber 300 Mbps: Starts around $59.95/mo
- EarthLink Fiber 1 Gig: Starts around $89.95/mo
- EarthLink Fiber 2 Gig+: $129.95/mo and up
🏆 Pricing Winner: Brightspeed. Cutting out the middleman saves you significant money. Brightspeed's 1 Gig plan is roughly $40 cheaper per month than EarthLink's 1 Gig plan.
Hidden Fees and Contracts
Be sure to read the fine print before signing up, as EarthLink's policies are stricter than Brightspeed's.
- Contracts:
- Brightspeed requires absolutely no annual contracts. You pay month-to-month and can cancel at any time.
- EarthLink frequently requires a 12-month contract for new internet installations, with early termination fees if you cancel early.
- Data Caps: Both providers offer 100% unlimited data with no overage charges.
- Equipment Fees:
- Brightspeed often includes its Wi-Fi gateway for free with fiber plans.
- EarthLink typically charges a mandatory equipment rental fee ranging from 9.95/moto14.95/mo, which is added to your base rate.
🏆 Hidden Fees Winner: Brightspeed. With no contracts and free equipment inclusions, Brightspeed is much more affordable and flexible.
Customer Service & Support
This is the one category where EarthLink shines.
- EarthLink: EarthLink justifies its higher prices by providing a premium customer service experience. They consistently rank higher than standard telecom giants in customer satisfaction because their call centers are highly responsive, and they actively manage network troubleshooting for you.
- Brightspeed: Brightspeed is a newer brand upgrading old, problematic networks. Their customer service ratings are currently average for the telecom industry. While improving, they cannot match EarthLink's premium support reputation.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Does EarthLink use Brightspeed's network?
Yes. Depending on your location, EarthLink frequently leases bandwidth on Brightspeed's physical DSL and fiber lines to deliver service to your home.
Why is EarthLink more expensive than Brightspeed?
EarthLink is a reseller. They have to pay wholesale fees to companies like Brightspeed, AT&T, and Frontier to use their physical cables, and they pass those costs onto the consumer. In exchange for the higher price, EarthLink provides premium, highly-rated customer support.
Does Brightspeed require a contract?
No. Brightspeed does not require an annual contract for its internet services. EarthLink, however, typically requires a 12-month agreement.
Are there data caps with either provider?
No. Both Brightspeed and EarthLink provide unlimited data with all of their primary home internet plans. You will not face data caps or overage charges with either company.
Can I use my own router with EarthLink?
While EarthLink allows you to use your own router, they often still mandate an equipment rental fee for the primary modem or ONT (Optical Network Terminal) required to connect to their partner's network. Brightspeed is generally more flexible regarding third-party equipment.
The Verdict: Which Provider Wins?
Choose Brightspeed if:
You want the most speed for the lowest price. Buying internet directly from the infrastructure owner (Brightspeed) cuts out the middleman, saving you money, eliminating annual contracts, and often waiving equipment fees.
Choose EarthLink if:
You are willing to pay a premium for exceptional customer service, or if Brightspeed will not directly service your address. EarthLink's support team is fantastic, making it a good choice for users who want a "managed" tech experience.
Ready to find out which provider has the best direct pricing at your home? Call our neutral national integration desk at right now to verify exact speed availability and unlock exclusive local promo codes for your address!